Unofficial fan site · not affiliated with Amazon MGM Studios / Prime Video or the show's producers · how we work

Fan theoryUpdated Nov 16, 2026 · 17 sources

Sauron in Season 3: Charlie Vickers and the One Ring Lore Debate

Season 3 of The Rings of Power centers on Sauron's ascension to power and the build-up to the creation of the One Ring. While media outlets highlight cleared-up past details and rewritten motivations, community discussions on Reddit show a split over Charlie Vickers' portrayal and how the show adapts Sauron's smithing lore.

Sauron's Ascension and the One Ring Build-Up

As Season 3 begins, coverage from Polygon and IGN tracks where the various rings are distributed among Men, Dwarves, and Elves, while Reddit users also discuss Sauron handing out rings. Show Snob highlights Sauron's inevitable ascension to power in the Episode 1 recap, and TVLine notes that the season clears up a confusing four-year detail regarding the character. Additionally, GamesRadar+ reports that the actor behind Celebrimbor shared a response to his character's surprise cameo in the third season.

A central storyline in Season 3 involves the build-up to the forging of the One Ring. ScreenRant reports that the season rewrites the reason Sauron creates the One Ring, alongside other lore adjustments noted by Polygon and MovieWeb regarding the Nazgul having a human side or a replacement that rewrites 72 years of lore. On Reddit, fans note that the plot so far follows Sauron searching for Celebrimbor's secret, leading to a prominent fan theory on r/ringsofpower that the show will save the actual forging of the One Ring for the final scene of the last episode as a season cliffhanger.

The Lore Debate: A Maia of Aule vs. Show Adaptation

The storyline of Sauron needing Celebrimbor's secrets to create the One Ring has sparked debate on r/ringsofpower. Critics of the plot point out that in literary canon, Sauron—originally named Mairon—was a Maia who served Aule, the Vala of craftsmanship, smithing, and creation. Because he was already an expert in ring craft and forging in the books, some viewers argue that his lack of knowledge in the show makes little sense.

Other viewers acknowledge the deviations from the books—including the One Ring storyline and the non-canonical dynamic between Sauron and Galadriel—but still find Season 3 to be an improvement over previous seasons. Meanwhile, a fan on r/ringsofpower pointed out that Sauron's Episode 2 dialogue comparing evil and power resembles a recognizable trope from Harry Potter.

Evaluating Charlie Vickers as the Dark Lord

Community opinion is also divided on Charlie Vickers' performance as Sauron in Season 3. While admirative posts on r/LOTR_on_Prime praise Vickers as the Dark Lord and Mairon the Admirable, other threads question whether his portrayal captures the terrifying nature of a demigod.

Some commentators on r/ringsofpower and r/LOTR_on_Prime feel Vickers' acting is too tame and resembles a human sorcerer rather than a Maia, suggesting he still feels like Halbrand or Annatar. One viewer expressed hope that when Sauron loses his fair appearance, he will look taller and more otherworldly as he did in the Season 1 prologue. Another viewer criticized the Episode 1 choreography, arguing it was a poor choice to show such a powerful being running after Galadriel in the woods until he was panting and unable to catch her.

Two sides of the debate

Critics of the Season 3 Portrayal and Lore Changes

  • As a Maia of Aule, the Vala of smithing and craftsmanship, Sauron should already be an expert in ring craft rather than needing Celebrimbor's secrets.
  • Charlie Vickers' Season 3 performance feels too tame, like a human sorcerer or his earlier Halbrand and Annatar personas, rather than a terrifying demigod.
  • Having Sauron run after Galadriel in the woods until he is panting in Episode 1 undermines his status as a powerful being.

Supporters of the Season 3 Direction

  • Even with deviations from the books regarding the One Ring storyline, Season 3 is better than the previous seasons.
  • Fans continue to praise Charlie Vickers' presence as The Dark Lord Sauron and Mairon the Admirable.
  • Sauron is still in his fair form, leaving room for him to become taller and more otherworldly like his Season 1 prologue appearance once he loses it.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: How do you feel about Sauron's portrayal and storyline in Season 3 so far?

Vote to see what other fans think.

Do you think the show's decision to have Sauron search for Celebrimbor's secret works for the television adaptation, or should he already know how to forge the One Ring on his own?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from Rings of Power S3