Unofficial fan site · not affiliated with Amazon MGM Studios / Prime Video or the show's producers · how we work

Fan theoryUpdated Nov 17, 2026 · 26 sources

Celeborn Returns: Jamie Campbell Bower, Gundabad, and Sauron Theories

A green cloak and two steaming goblets left beside an iron chain hoist in a snowy stone cavern under a stormy sky.
Illustration made for this site, not from the show.

Season 3 officially introduces Jamie Campbell Bower as Galadriel's lover Celeborn after the production considered hundreds of auditions. While their forest flashbacks and Episode 4 reunion in Gundabad have drawn praise from viewers, a trailer and creator reports for Episodes 5 and 6 have sparked fan theories that Sauron will capture Celeborn to lure Galadriel and possibly take his form.

Casting Jamie Campbell Bower as Celeborn

Season 3 of The Rings of Power officially introduces Jamie Campbell Bower as Galadriel's lover, Celeborn, alongside returning star Morfydd Clark. According to Collider, the production considered hundreds of auditions before casting the role. Speaking to IGN, Bower described joining Season 3 as the "perfect kind of antidote" after his time on Stranger Things, while Clark told The Times of India and Cinema Express that playing Galadriel is a dream come true.

The romance between Celeborn and Galadriel has prompted Vulture to note that the series is leaning into "romantasy" in Season 3. In a TikTok post by @thedirect.com, Bower and co-star Charlie Vickers also discussed the unique connection that Celeborn and Sauron share through Galadriel.

Flashbacks and the Episode 4 Reunion in Gundabad

Viewers and Reddit users on r/LOTR_on_Prime have highlighted the flashback scene showing how Celeborn and Galadriel met, describing Galadriel moving through the trees, a fight among the leaves, and dancing until dawn in a magical forest at night. Fans on r/LOTR_on_Prime also compared the show's depiction of their early days to published Silmarillion material, where Celeborn dwelt in Doriath and shared a great love with Galadriel.

In the present timeline, the pair reunite in Season 3, Episode 4, titled "Gundabad," an installment that Decider recapped as a jailbreak episode. Fan discussion on r/LOTR_on_Prime praised Celeborn's presence at Gundabad, noting how he charged at a "Naznagol" without knowing the latest developments while Theo and Arondir had a dark family reunion nearby. TikTok creators including @celedrielfiles and @keditzl1 also celebrated the long-awaited reunion.

Episodes 5 and 6: Sauron Capture and Shapeshifting Theories

Before completing the first four episodes, at least one viewer on r/LOTR_on_Prime admitted to theorizing that Celeborn was actually Sauron in disguise across different timelines. While the first four episodes established Celeborn as his own character, a trailer for Episodes 5 and 6 has ignited new fan theories about Sauron's plans for him.

According to a fan discussion post on r/LOTR_on_Prime, the trailer for Episodes 5 and 6 shows Celeborn captured while Sauron tells him, "She'll come to you, but she'll come for me." That Reddit user theorized that Sauron might shapeshift into Celeborn's form to trick Galadriel into revealing information about a "missing piece," which the poster speculates is the silver and gold from Valinor. Meanwhile, TikTok creator @forestelfsoul posted an unverified theory and report claiming that Sauron will hunt down the pair in Episodes 5 and 6, and that Celeborn will probably get captured again to save Galadriel as part of Sauron's plan to lure her in.

Two sides of the debate

Sauron Will Impersonate Celeborn

  • A fan theory on r/LOTR_on_Prime suggests that after capturing Celeborn in the trailer for Episodes 5 and 6, Sauron will shapeshift into Celeborn's form to deceive Galadriel.
  • The same r/LOTR_on_Prime theory proposes that Sauron needs this disguise so Galadriel will tell him about a missing piece, speculated to be the silver and gold from Valinor.
  • Suspicion of a disguise has already been on viewers' minds, with one r/LOTR_on_Prime user noting they initially thought Celeborn was Sauron in disguise during the first four episodes.

Celeborn Is Bait in Sauron's Trap

  • In the trailer for Episodes 5 and 6 discussed on r/LOTR_on_Prime, Sauron tells a captured Celeborn, "She'll come to you, but she'll come for me," pointing directly to a trap meant to draw Galadriel in.
  • TikTok creator @forestelfsoul suggests that Celeborn will probably get captured again while saving Galadriel, which serves Sauron's plan to lure Galadriel to him.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: What is Sauron's plan for a captured Celeborn in Episodes 5 and 6?

Vote to see what other fans think.

Do you think Sauron will actually take Celeborn's form to deceive Galadriel, or is he only using Celeborn as bait to draw her out?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from Rings of Power S3

ConfirmedMarnukh the Orc, Numenor's Politics, and Season 3's Side Plots DebatedSeason 3 of The Rings of Power introduces major character arcs and side plots across its opening four episodes, headlined by Episode 1, titled 'Marnukh.' While official interviews and reviews highlight the creative risks and fresh perspectives of an Orc traveling with Elves, alongside shifting politics in Numenor and developments in Khazad-dum, fan discussions on Reddit and TikTok show a split community debating how well these stories land.ConfirmedThe Rings of Power Season 3 Release Schedule: Episode 5 Drop TimeThe Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 premiered on November 11 on Amazon Prime Video, with the first four episodes currently available. Official social media updates confirm that the series continues on Wednesdays, while numerous outlets have published guides covering the upcoming release of Episode 5.ConfirmedSeason 3 Reviews and Fan Reactions: Tomatometer vs. CritiquesThe release of The Rings of Power Season 3 has sparked debate across media outlets and fan communities. While some coverage highlights a record-setting or solid Tomatometer score and praises the first four episodes, other reports note the score debuted at a series low. Fans on Reddit and TikTok are equally split between praising the visuals and questioning the writing, budget, and critic access.Fan theorySauron in Season 3: Charlie Vickers and the One Ring Lore DebateSeason 3 of The Rings of Power centers on Sauron's ascension to power and the build-up to the creation of the One Ring. While media outlets highlight cleared-up past details and rewritten motivations, community discussions on Reddit and TikTok show a split over Charlie Vickers' portrayal and how the show adapts Sauron's smithing lore.