Unofficial fan site · not affiliated with Amazon MGM Studios / Prime Video or the show's producers · how we work

ConfirmedUpdated Nov 17, 2026 · 28 sources

Season 3 Reviews and Fan Reactions: Tomatometer vs. Critiques

Macro view of a brass scale balancing a red glass orb and rough slag in golden light, with tongs and two steaming cups.
Illustration made for this site, not from the show.

The release of The Rings of Power Season 3 has sparked debate across media outlets and fan communities. While some coverage highlights a record-setting or solid Tomatometer score and praises the first four episodes, other reports note the score debuted at a series low. Fans on Reddit and TikTok are equally split between praising the visuals and questioning the writing, budget, and critic access.

Conflicting Headlines on Rotten Tomatoes Scores

Following the premiere of The Rings of Power Season 3 on Prime Video, media outlets offered contrasting takes on its Rotten Tomatoes reception. ScreenRant published an article examining six reasons the season achieved a record-setting Tomatometer score, while Forbes noted it arrived with a solid score. Both ScreenRant and The Hype Magazine also covered the debut of the official Rotten Tomatoes audience verdict.

Other outlets framed the numbers differently. GamesRadar+ reported that while Season 3 debuted to a solid Rotten Tomatoes score, it was the lowest yet for the series. Collider ran a headline stating the show officially hit a new low as Season 3 premiered. Exact score percentages are not detailed in these reports.

General review coverage also varied in tone. NewsBreak called Season 3 an exciting, cinematic experience, and SlashFilm explored why the season feels like a reboot. Meanwhile, outlets like Esquire, Decider, Substack, and India News Network published pieces assessing the show's ongoing appeal and questioning whether it is still worth watching.

Fan Praise for Visuals, Lore, and Rewatch Value

Across fan communities, many viewers have shared enthusiastic reactions to the first four episodes. In fan discussions on r/LOTR_on_Prime, users praised the season as visually stunning and entertaining, pointing to the costumes, locations, and lore references as finally meeting adaptation expectations. Another fan noted watching all four episodes three times, applauding the nuances in the performances and details like Sauron standing with a spear.

On r/ringsofpower, one fan highlighted the gorgeous camera work, CGI, and costumes in Episode 3, specifically mentioning the wide landscape shots, a bird turning into a raven, an orc arriving in front of Elrond as Gil-galad watches, and the costumes for Sauron and his Nazgul. Another user argued the show's graphics, multi-dimensional elves and dwarf king, and portrayal of Sauron as more than an eye make it better written and directed than the Lord of the Rings movies.

Several fans also pushed back against online negativity. A TikTok creator report from @bf8_alt called the show over-hated, while @celebreabird shared an Episode 3 review. On Reddit, fans appreciated balanced analyses like New Zealand author Daniel Stride's review of Episodes 1 through 4, noted the show improved once they stopped watching negative YouTube breakdowns, and defended treating Middle-earth like Norse mythology with room for different interpretations, praising Arondir as a favorite character.

Community Critiques on Pacing, Budget, and Access Media

Not all fan discussion has been positive, even among long-time viewers. One r/ringsofpower user called Season 3 the best of a bad batch, while another stated that despite Episode 4 being a favorite, the season overall felt like a letdown so far due to unnecessary tragedy. On r/LOTR_on_Prime, a fan argued that Seasons 1 and 2 were much better because the uncertainty surrounding Halbrand's true nature fit Sauron's title as the Great Deceiver.

Specific production choices also drew criticism in fan discussions. A user on r/LOTR_on_Prime questioned whether the show still had the huge financial support of Season 1, noting that after Episode 1 showed a map of Sauron's invasion, the actual conflict was just a small skirmish in the woods rather than a massive battle like Finrod's in the first season. Another fan on r/ringsofpower felt the summary narration at the start of Season 3 was a bit tacky compared to Cate Blanchett's prologue in The Fellowship of the Ring.

Finally, some fans questioned the critical consensus itself. A discussion post on r/ringsofpower argued that barely any critics reviewed Season 3 compared to previous seasons, claiming that positive reviews mostly came from access media like Nerdist and Collider who received special set and cast access from Amazon, whereas independent critics gave moderate to negative reviews.

Two sides of the debate

Season 3 Hits Its Stride

  • Outlets like ScreenRant and Forbes report strong or record-setting Rotten Tomatoes scores, with NewsBreak calling it an exciting, cinematic experience.
  • Fans praise the gorgeous cinematography, CGI, and costumes—especially for Sauron and the Nazgul—alongside deeper lore references.
  • Viewers highlight high rewatch value across the first four episodes and engaging character nuances that improve on previous seasons.

Season 3 Falls Short

  • GamesRadar+ and Collider report the season debuted to a series-low score, while Reddit users argue positive reviews mostly come from access media.
  • Some fans question if the budget was reduced after seeing a small woodland skirmish instead of a large-scale invasion battle.
  • Viewers critique the tacky opening narration, unnecessary tragedy, and the loss of the Halbrand mystery that drove Seasons 1 and 2.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: How do you rate The Rings of Power Season 3 through the first four episodes?

Vote to see what other fans think.

Do you agree with the positive reviews praising Season 3's visuals and cinematography, or do you share the critiques regarding the show's scale and storytelling?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from Rings of Power S3

Fan theoryCeleborn Returns: Jamie Campbell Bower, Gundabad, and Sauron TheoriesSeason 3 officially introduces Jamie Campbell Bower as Galadriel's lover Celeborn after the production considered hundreds of auditions. While their forest flashbacks and Episode 4 reunion in Gundabad have drawn praise from viewers, a trailer and creator reports for Episodes 5 and 6 have sparked fan theories that Sauron will capture Celeborn to lure Galadriel and possibly take his form.ConfirmedMarnukh the Orc, Numenor's Politics, and Season 3's Side Plots DebatedSeason 3 of The Rings of Power introduces major character arcs and side plots across its opening four episodes, headlined by Episode 1, titled 'Marnukh.' While official interviews and reviews highlight the creative risks and fresh perspectives of an Orc traveling with Elves, alongside shifting politics in Numenor and developments in Khazad-dum, fan discussions on Reddit and TikTok show a split community debating how well these stories land.ConfirmedThe Rings of Power Season 3 Release Schedule: Episode 5 Drop TimeThe Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 premiered on November 11 on Amazon Prime Video, with the first four episodes currently available. Official social media updates confirm that the series continues on Wednesdays, while numerous outlets have published guides covering the upcoming release of Episode 5.Fan theorySauron in Season 3: Charlie Vickers and the One Ring Lore DebateSeason 3 of The Rings of Power centers on Sauron's ascension to power and the build-up to the creation of the One Ring. While media outlets highlight cleared-up past details and rewritten motivations, community discussions on Reddit and TikTok show a split over Charlie Vickers' portrayal and how the show adapts Sauron's smithing lore.